
Focus and Concentration
Attention and Memory: Why You Can't Remember What You Never Noticed
You have seen the Apple logo thousands of times, yet you probably cannot draw it. Why attention decides what you remember, what two classic studies found, and how to notice on purpose.
Try this before you read on. Take a piece of paper and draw the Apple logo from memory. Not roughly. Which way does the leaf point? Which side is the bite on? Is there anything at the bottom?
Now look it up.
If yours was wrong, you are in good company. You have probably seen that logo thousands of times, on phones, laptops, shop fronts and adverts. Seeing it thousands of times did not put it in your memory, because seeing is not the same as noticing.
That is the whole relationship between attention and memory in one small test. What you never really noticed, you cannot remember. Not because your memory is bad, but because the information never went in.
Attention is the gate
The way I think about it, everything you remember starts with attention. Your senses take in far more than you could ever hold, and attention is the gate that decides what gets through to be remembered.
So when someone says "I have a terrible memory", very often what they mean is "I wasn't paying attention." The name at the party, the place you put your keys, the point your manager made in the meeting. It is hard to forget something you never took in. How Memory Works (A Practical Guide) covers the full picture of how information gets in and stays.
Two studies, more than 35 years apart, show just how much we miss.
The research: Nickerson and Adams, 1979
In short: People who handled pennies every day could not remember the details of a penny.
What they did: Raymond Nickerson and Marilyn Jager Adams ran a set of experiments on the US one-cent coin. They asked people to draw a penny from memory, to place its features in the right position, to say which features appeared on it, and to pick the correct drawing from 15 versions.
Who was involved: US adults and students: 20 people in each of the first three experiments, 127 students judging drawings, and 36 students choosing the most likely correct one.
What they found: When drawing from memory, people recalled and correctly placed a median of three of the eight main features. Only one person got all eight. Asked to pick the real penny from 15 drawings, fewer than half chose the correct one, and several wrong versions looked just as convincing.
What they concluded: Even a very familiar object is poorly held in memory in detail. The authors suggested that we keep the details we need for a purpose, and a penny only needs to be recognised as a penny.
The research: Blake, Nazarian and Castel, 2015
In short: Only one of 85 students could draw the Apple logo perfectly from memory, and people were far more confident than they should have been.
What they did: Researchers at the University of California, Los Angeles asked students to draw the Apple logo from memory and rate how confident they were, then to pick the real logo from eight versions with small changes.
Who was involved: 85 undergraduates in the first experiment, most of them Apple users, and 26 in a second.
What they found: Only one of the 85 drew the logo perfectly. Fewer than half picked the real logo out of the eight. In the second experiment, people rated their confidence before and after drawing: it averaged about 8.6 out of 10 before, and about 5.5 after they had tried to draw it. Apple users did not do noticeably better than PC users.
What they concluded: Seeing something often makes it feel familiar and makes you confident you know it, without giving you a good memory of the details. Trying to recall it brought people's confidence back down to earth.
What I take from it
Familiar is not the same as remembered. Your brain is very good at recognising things it has seen before. The details, it seems, are kept only when you have a reason to need them.
The second thing I take from these studies is the confidence. Before people tried to draw the logo, they were sure they knew it. Trying to recall it is what showed them the gap, and that makes testing yourself a good way to find out what you really know. The Testing Effect (Roediger and Karpicke 2006) Explained goes into that.
Why you do not notice
I think of your brain as a filter, and that is a good thing. If you noticed every detail of every coin, logo, face and doorway, you would never get anything done.
The way I picture it, the filter works on one question: does this matter? The penny only needs to be recognised as money. The logo only needs to be recognised as Apple. Your keys only need to be put down so your hands are free. Nothing in those moments tells your brain "this is important, keep it", so it doesn't.
Change the answer to that question and you change what you notice. You will have had this yourself: you buy a new jacket or a new car, and suddenly you see the same one everywhere. Nothing changed out there. What changed is what your brain was told was important. Psychologists call that selective attention, and What is Priming in Psychology? The Memory You Never Notice explains how it differs from priming.
What I see in my coaching is a second filter: how busy your head already is. When your mind is on something else, there is less attention left for what is in front of you, and you can look straight at something and still miss it. How to Improve Concentration: Three Strategies That Hold Up covers how to clear the space.
Try it the next time you put your keys down: stop the conversation in your head for one second as they leave your hand.
How to notice on purpose
The good news is that attention can be directed. You do not need to notice everything. You need to notice the right things at the right moment. Here is how.
1. Decide what matters before it happens
Before you walk into a meeting, a party or a lecture, ask yourself one question: what do I want to remember from this? The names of the people I meet. The three numbers in the presentation. The deadline. Asking the question tells you what to look out for, and I find you then start to spot it.
The simplest way I know to prime yourself is to ask the right question. "What's interesting about this?" works for anything you have to read or listen to.
2. Look for one detail that stands out
You cannot take in everything, so pick one thing. With a person, one distinctive feature of their face. With an object, one detail you would not have expected. With a page, one idea that surprised you.
One detail, noticed properly, gives your memory something to hold. How to Remember Names: A Five-Step Framework That Actually Works uses exactly this step to fix a name to a face.
3. Give it a picture or a meaning
What I find is that noticing gets the information in the door, and meaning is what keeps it there. Meaning is one of the four ingredients in Creative Memorisation: The Four Ingredients That Make Anything Memorable. Link the detail to something you already know, or turn it into a small picture: the bite on the right of the apple, and the leaf on top leaning the same way, as if it is peering over to see who took the bite.
That one picture, silly as it is, gives you two details that are easy to get wrong.
4. Say it out loud
Say what you have noticed, quietly or in your head if you have to. "Keys, on the shelf by the door." "Sarah, from finance, red glasses." I find putting it into words gives you a second way in, and it makes the moment of noticing more definite. How to Remember Things: Keys, Errands and What You Came In For shows how to turn this into a habit for the things you put down.
5. Check yourself straight away
Before you move on, try to recall it. Picture the face and say the name. Close your eyes and picture where the keys are. If it is not there, you get to look again while you still can.
Checking straight away is how you find the gap before it matters.
Try it now: the drawing test
The studies give you a simple exercise you can do in two minutes.
- Pick something you see every day but have never really looked at: a coin, the logo on your phone, your front door, the face of your watch.
- Draw it from memory, in as much detail as you can.
- Rate how confident you are, from 1 to 10.
- Go and look at the real thing. Notice what you got wrong.
- Now look at it properly for 30 seconds. Pick out the details. Say them out loud. Give the odd ones a picture.
- Tomorrow, draw it again.
You will see the difference between seeing something and noticing it, and you may see how quickly noticing on purpose makes a difference.
Where this shows up in your life
Think about where forgetting costs you most, and you will usually find attention behind it.
Names. You were thinking about what to say next, so the name never went in.
Where you put things. You put your keys down while thinking about something else, so there was no moment to remember.
What you read. Your eyes went over the words while your mind was elsewhere. Priming the page first, with a question, changes that.
Meetings and calls. You heard the point, but you did not decide it mattered, so it was gone by the evening.
In each case, the fix is the same. Decide what matters, notice one thing properly, give it meaning, and check it.
A plan for this week
- Do the drawing test with one everyday object today.
- Before each meeting or call, ask: what do I want to remember from this?
- Every time you put your keys or phone down, say where out loud.
- Every new person you meet, pick one feature and say their name back.
- At the end of each day, recall three things you noticed on purpose.
Where to go next
For the full picture of how memory works, How Memory Works (A Practical Guide). For the brain's own filter, What is Priming in Psychology? The Memory You Never Notice. For holding your focus, How to Improve Concentration: Three Strategies That Hold Up. And for the things you put down, How to Remember Things: Keys, Errands and What You Came In For.
Memory map
- Seeing is not the same as noticing: you cannot remember what never went in. Image: a pair of wide-open eyes with a closed door behind them.
- Think of attention as the gate that decides what gets through to be remembered. Image: a narrow gate with a crowd of objects queuing and only one slipping through.
- The penny study: a median of three of eight features recalled, and fewer than half picked the right coin. Image: a coin with most of its face rubbed blank.
- The Apple logo study: one person in 85 drew it perfectly. Image: a page of wonky apple drawings with one perfect apple in the middle.
- People were confident until they tried to draw it. Image: a person puffing out their chest, then deflating as they pick up a pencil.
- Picture your brain filtering on one question: does this matter? Image: a sieve catching one glowing object while grey ones fall through.
- Decide what matters before it happens: ask what you want to remember. Image: a person pausing at a door with a question mark floating above them.
- Look for one detail that stands out, give it a picture, and say it out loud. Image: a face in sharp focus with one feature lit up and a speech bubble beside it.
- The bite is on the right and the leaf leans the same way, peering over at it. Image: an apple with a bite out of its right side, its leaf leaning over to peer at the gap.
- Check yourself straight away; testing shows the gap. Image: a person closing their eyes to picture keys on a shelf, then opening them to check.
- The drawing test: draw an everyday object, check it, look properly, draw it again tomorrow. Image: two drawings of a wristwatch side by side, the second far more detailed.
Sources
- Nickerson, R. S., and Adams, M. J. (1979). Long-term memory for a common object. Cognitive Psychology, 11(3), 287 to 307. https://doi.org/10.1016/0010-0285(79)90013-6
- Blake, A. B., Nazarian, M., and Castel, A. D. (2015). The Apple of the mind's eye: everyday attention, metamemory, and reconstructive memory for the Apple logo. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 68(5), 858 to 865. https://doi.org/10.1080/17470218.2014.1002798
- Roediger, H. L., III, and Karpicke, J. D. (2006). Test-enhanced learning: taking memory tests improves long-term retention. Psychological Science, 17(3), 249 to 255. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2006.01693.x (the home for this study is The Testing Effect (Roediger and Karpicke 2006) Explained)
Loci
Build the memory palace in this article inside Loci — store your locations, link images, and rehearse with spaced repetition.
Try it in LociMemory School community
Learn directly with Mark inside the Memory School community on Skool — monthly lessons, practice, and Q&A.
Join Memory SchoolAbout the author
Mark Channon
Grand Master of Memory (1995). Author of three books on memory published by Hodder and Nick Hern. Creator of BBC1's Monkhouse's Memory Masters. Memory coach on Channel 4's Can I Improve My Memory?
Read full bio →