Can Mindfulness Improve Working Memory? (Mrazek 2013) Explained

    Focus and Concentration

    Can Mindfulness Improve Working Memory? (Mrazek 2013) Explained

    In 2013, two weeks of mindfulness training improved students' working memory and reading test scores, and their minds wandered less, compared with a nutrition class. What that study did, what a 2019 study added, what neither shows, and a ten-week plan to test it on yourself.

    By Published Updated

    At 13, growing up in Aberdeen, I got into hypnosis. The plan was simple: control the minds of my friends. I later found out it does not work that way. All hypnosis is self-hypnosis, and I was gutted. But the disappointment led me somewhere better. It led me into meditation, and I have meditated ever since.

    So in 2013, while I was writing The Memory Workbook, one study stopped me in my tracks. Can mindfulness improve working memory? In that study, yes. Forty-eight students who took a two-week mindfulness course improved their working memory and their scores on a reading test, and their minds wandered less, compared with students who took a two-week course on nutrition. A second study, in 2019, found a similar pattern from 13 minutes of meditation a day, but only after eight weeks.

    Promising, with limits worth knowing. Here are both studies, what they do not show, and a ten-week plan for running your own version.

    Why working memory is worth training

    Working memory is the small space where you hold something while you use it. The start of a sentence while you read to its end. A phone number while you dial. The three images you have just placed in a memory palace, a route through a familiar place where you leave pictures in order, while you build the fourth. It holds only a handful of things at once, and everything you learn passes through it on the way in.

    Mind wandering takes up room in that space. If part of your attention is replaying this morning's meeting, or planning what to cook tonight, that part is not available for the page in front of you. You get to the bottom of a paragraph and realise none of it landed. People call that a bad memory. My own "bad memory" in the nineties turned out to be attention that would not stay put.

    So the question behind this research matters to anyone who learns anything. If wandering eats into working memory, can you train the wandering down and win some of that room back?

    The research

    The research: Mrazek and colleagues, 2013

    • In short: Students who were randomly given a two-week mindfulness course improved their working memory and their reading comprehension scores, and their minds wandered less, compared with students given a two-week nutrition course.
    • What they did: Students were randomly assigned to one of two classes, each lasting two weeks: mindfulness or nutrition. Before and after, the researchers measured working memory, reading comprehension using questions from the GRE (a graduate entry test), and how much the students' minds wandered.
    • Who was involved: 48 undergraduates at the University of California, Santa Barbara, in Jonathan Schooler's lab. The lead author is Michael Mrazek.
    • What they found: The mindfulness group improved their working memory capacity, raised their GRE reading comprehension by about 16 percentile points, and showed less mind wandering during testing. The nutrition group did not show these gains.
    • What they concluded: A short mindfulness course improved focus and working memory, and the drop in mind wandering helped explain why the test scores went up.

    The detail that makes this study worth taking seriously is the comparison group. The nutrition students were on a two-week course too. So the mindfulness gains cannot simply be put down to turning up to a class and feeling looked after.

    The research: Basso and colleagues, 2019

    • In short: People new to meditation who did 13 minutes of guided meditation every day showed better attention, working memory and mood after eight weeks, but not after four.
    • What they did: Participants were assigned either to 13 minutes a day of guided meditation or to 13 minutes a day of listening to a podcast, and were tested at four weeks and again at eight.
    • Who was involved: Adults with no meditation experience, in Wendy Suzuki's lab at New York University.
    • What they found: At the eight-week point the meditation group had improved in attention, working memory and mood. At four weeks there was no such gain. The paper's title also reports benefits for emotional regulation.
    • What they concluded: A brief daily meditation can improve attention and mood in beginners, but the benefits took eight weeks to show.

    The podcast group matters for the same reason the nutrition class did. They also gave up 13 minutes a day. The difference was what they did with them.

    What kind of evidence this is

    Both are single randomised studies with an active comparison group. That is a good design. People were put into groups by chance, and the comparison group did something rather than nothing, which rules out a lot of easy explanations.

    But each is one study. Mrazek's was 48 students, a modest number, so the evidence is moderate: solid enough to act on, not enough to call settled. Basso's is preliminary: one study, and the gains appeared only at the second checkpoint. And Mrazek tested a whole mindfulness course. It supports mindfulness as taught on that course, not any one exercise you might find online.

    What I take from it

    First, I owe you a correction. When I have told this study on stage, it has sometimes come out as "they got better results in their exams". That is not right. What improved was their score on the reading comprehension section of the GRE, a test the researchers gave as part of the study. It is still a striking result. It just is not exam results, and I would rather say it accurately than say it big.

    Second, I think I know why mindfulness has studies like this and hypnosis mostly does not. Hypnosis was very flaky in terms of the research. Then along came mindfulness, and it had a very strict structure: set steps, set timings, easy to teach the same way twice. Structure makes something researchable. Having trained in both, I see a lot of what I do as very similar to mindfulness; the factor that changes is the person doing the thing. That is my view; nobody has tested it. And the looser practices are not shown to fail. They are mostly untested, which is a different thing.

    Third, the goal is not an empty mind. Your mind will wander, every session, for as long as you practise. What you are training is single-tasking: giving your attention to one thing, the breath, noticing when it has gone and guiding it back. Do not beat yourself up when it drifts or tell yourself you are failing. A session full of drifting is a session full of chances to come back.

    Fourth, the two studies together give you a plan. In one, a two-week course was enough to show change. In the other, a short daily sit took eight weeks. So begin with something structured and short, expect weeks rather than days, and do not judge it at the first checkpoint.

    What these studies do not show

    This research gets stretched, so here are the plain warnings.

    • Not exam results. Mrazek measured GRE reading comprehension, given within the study.
    • Not a higher IQ. Neither paper claims mindfulness makes you more intelligent. Be wary of anyone who sells it that way.
    • Not proof for one particular exercise. Mrazek tested a two-week course. It does not prove the three-minute breathing space (a short, three-step mindfulness exercise) works, or any other single technique, mine included.
    • Not "proven to increase focus". Basso is one preliminary study. "Better attention in beginners after eight weeks" is as far as it goes.
    • Not the forehead spot. I have described a practice of resting your attention on a point about an inch behind your forehead in the same breath as the Suzuki lab study. That is a separate practice. The study used 13 minutes of guided meditation, and the two should be kept apart.
    • Not a lasting change, necessarily. Mrazek compared students before and after a two-week course. It cannot tell you how long the gains last once you stop.
    • Not quick for everyone. In Basso, four weeks showed nothing measurable. Quit at four weeks because nothing has happened and you quit right before the point where that study found a change.

    How to use it: a ten-week plan

    How to Improve Concentration: Three Strategies That Hold Up covers the three-minute breathing space and how to hang a short practice on a habit you already have. This plan is the longer game, shaped around the two studies.

    Weeks one and two: make it a course. Mrazek tested a course, not something people dipped into when they remembered. So give your fortnight the feel of one. Choose a daily time. Put a start date and an end date in your diary. If you can, follow a class or a guided series rather than inventing each session as you go. Short sessions are fine. What matters is the structure and that you show up.

    Weeks three to ten: the 13-minute sit. Sit where nobody will interrupt you, close your eyes, breathe through your nose and give your attention to the breath. Each time your mind wanders, notice where it went and bring it back. Set a timer that sounds at 13 minutes, because somewhere around minute eight, nine or ten you will start asking yourself whether it is done yet. That question is just one more wander to notice. Thirteen minutes matches the daily dose in the Basso study; their practice was a guided one, so if you prefer a voice in your ear, use a guided recording of the same length.

    Watch your drift while you read. Mrazek measured mind wandering during a reading test, so measure yours the same way. When you read to learn, hold a pencil. Each time you catch yourself reading without taking anything in, put a small dot in the margin and go back to the start of that paragraph. Count the dots at the end of each chapter. Over the weeks you are looking for the catches to come sooner, and then for there to be fewer of them.

    Give yourself a rough working memory check. On day one, and again at weeks two, four and eight, have someone read you a string of digits once and try to say them back in reverse order. Start at four digits and add one each time you get it right. Note your best. This is a home check, not a lab test, and it will move with sleep and mood, but a number in a notebook beats a vague feeling.

    Write "keep going" in your diary at week four. That is where the Basso group showed no change yet. You want a note from your past self waiting there.

    Miss a day, sit the next one. Consistency beats length. A missed day does not end the course, and a wandering session is not a failed one.

    Where this fits

    Mindfulness will not do your learning for you. What the research suggests is that it can give you back some of the room that a wandering mind takes up, and that room is where every memory technique does its work. For the space itself, read What is Working Memory?. For the short daily practices and how to make them stick, How to Improve Concentration: Three Strategies That Hold Up. For getting into the right state at your desk, How to Focus Better: A Memory Coach's Method. And for just how little working memory holds, The Magical Number Seven, and Why It Is Really Four.

    Memory map

    1. At 13 I tried hypnosis to control my friends' minds; all hypnosis is self-hypnosis, and it led me into meditation. Image: a teenage boy swinging a pocket watch in front of three unimpressed friends.
    2. Can mindfulness improve working memory? In a 2013 study of 48 students, yes. Image: rows of students sitting cross-legged on cushions in a lecture theatre.
    3. The comparison group took a two-week nutrition course, so it was not just turning up to a class. Image: two classrooms side by side, one heaped with vegetables, one scattered with cushions.
    4. Working memory up, mind wandering down, reading scores up about 16 percentile points. Image: a balloon rising while a kite on a long string is reeled back in.
    5. It was the GRE reading section given in the study, not exam results. Image: a magnifying glass resting on a single sheet of paper in an empty room.
    6. Thirteen minutes a day showed gains in attention, working memory and mood at eight weeks, not four. Image: a bare green shoot that stays small for weeks, then bursts into flower.
    7. Structure makes something researchable: mindfulness has set steps, hypnosis was looser (my view). Image: a neat line of stepping stones beside a foggy marsh.
    8. The skill is noticing the drift and coming back, not an empty mind. Image: a sheepdog steering one stray sheep back to the flock.
    9. Weeks one and two as a course, then a 13-minute sit with a timer. Image: a diary with a fortnight circled and a small brass gong beside it.
    10. A pencil dot in the margin every time you drift while reading. Image: a pencil hovering over the margin of an open book.
    11. Judge it at eight weeks, not four. Image: a walker striding past a halfway post on a hill path without looking back.

    Sources

    • Mark Channon, The Memory Workbook (Hodder Education)
    • Mark Channon, Memory School course lessons Meditating for Flow and 3 Minute Breathing Space (video)
    • Mrazek, M. D., Franklin, M. S., Phillips, D. T., Baird, B., and Schooler, J. W. (2013). Mindfulness training improves working memory capacity and GRE performance while reducing mind wandering. Psychological Science, 24(5), 776 to 781. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797612459659
    • Basso, J. C., McHale, A., Ende, V., Oberlin, D. J., and Suzuki, W. A. (2019). Brief, daily meditation enhances attention, memory, mood, and emotional regulation in non-experienced meditators. Behavioural Brain Research, 356, 208 to 220. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bbr.2018.08.023

    Are you old school? Get Mark's book The Memory Workbook and dive in depth.

    Loci

    Build the memory palace in this article inside Loci — store your locations, link images, and rehearse with spaced repetition.

    Try it in Loci

    Memory School community

    Learn directly with Mark inside the Memory School community on Skool — monthly lessons, practice, and Q&A.

    Join Memory School

    About the author

    Grand Master of Memory (1995). Author of three books on memory published by Hodder and Nick Hern. Creator of BBC1's Monkhouse's Memory Masters. Memory coach on Channel 4's Can I Improve My Memory?

    Read full bio →