Does Mental Rehearsal Work? What the Research Shows

    Memory Training

    Does Mental Rehearsal Work? What the Research Shows

    Running a performance in your head before you do it for real: what a 1994 meta-analysis and its 2020 follow-up found, how big the effect is, and how to rehearse in your mind so it adds to real practice.

    By Published Updated

    You lie in bed the night before a big presentation and run it through. The walk to the front. The first line. The slide that always sticks. The question you are dreading, and your answer to it. By the time you fall asleep you have given the talk three times, and you have not said a word out loud.

    Athletes do it before a race. Musicians run a piece in their heads on the train. Actors run their lines in the wings. It feels useful. But does mental rehearsal actually make the real thing better, or does it just make you feel prepared?

    The research has looked at this question for decades. The answer is yes, it helps. It helps less than doing the real thing, and it works best alongside it.

    What mental rehearsal is

    Mental rehearsal, which researchers usually call mental practice, means going through a task in your mind without physically doing it. You picture the movements, the order, the moments that matter. For a talk, you see the room and hear yourself. For a tennis serve, you feel the toss and the swing. For a piano piece, you hear the notes and sense your fingers moving.

    It is different from daydreaming about success. Mental rehearsal runs the task itself, step by step, as if you were doing it.

    The research

    The research: Driskell, Copper and Moran, 1994

    • In short: Rehearsing a task in your head improves how well you do it for real.
    • What they did: Driskell, Copper and Moran ran a meta-analysis, a study that pools the results of many earlier experiments. They gathered studies that compared people who practised a task in their minds with people who did not practise at all.
    • Who was involved: The pooled studies covered a wide range of tasks, mostly motor and thinking tasks in a lab rather than elite performers.
    • What they found: Mental practice had a positive, significant effect on performance. How much it helped depended on three things: the kind of task, how long the mental practice went on, and how long after practising people performed.
    • What they concluded: Mental practice is an effective way to improve performance. It helps less than physical practice, so it works best as an addition to it.

    What kind of evidence is this? A meta-analysis: it pools many experiments, which makes it stronger than any single study. Most of those experiments used lab tasks rather than elite performers.

    The research: Toth, McNeill, Hayes, Moran and Campbell, 2020

    • In short: Twenty-four years later, mental practice still helped, but the effect was small.
    • What they did: Toth and colleagues repeated the 1994 analysis on the studies that had come out since, to see whether the finding still held.
    • Who was involved: 37 studies published between 1995 and 2018.
    • What they found: Mental practice still improved performance. The size of the effect was small.
    • What they concluded: The benefit is real and has held up across decades of research, but it is modest.

    What kind of evidence is this? A second meta-analysis, built to check the first. It confirms the direction of the effect and puts a smaller number on it.

    One more study, from the Olympics

    In a study of 235 Canadian Olympians from the 1984 Games, Orlick and Partington found that certain mental skills were linked to how well athletes performed. Mental preparation is part of how top performers get ready.

    What I take from it

    Three things stand out for me.

    It works, and it is an add-on. Both meta-analyses point the same way: rehearsing in your head makes the real thing better. Neither says it can replace doing it. So I treat mental rehearsal as a way to get more out of the practice you are already doing, not a shortcut around it.

    When matters. The 1994 analysis found that the gap between practising and performing made a difference. So rehearse reasonably close to when you need it.

    For memory, rehearsal is recall. In my view, rehearsal on your feet is the most powerful kind of active recall. You are not reading and repeating. You are looking for the words, with the blocking and the emotion rolled up in them, and you are testing yourself the whole time without the pressure of a test. That is where I see the testing effect at work. A run in your head is a lighter version of the same thing: you still have to find each piece. The Testing Effect (Roediger and Karpicke 2006) Explained covers the research behind it.

    What the research does not show

    Three things these studies do not show.

    • Not that it replaces practice. Physical practice still does more. Mental rehearsal adds to it.
    • Not that the effect is big. The 2020 follow-up found it small.
    • Not that visualising success makes it happen. These studies tested rehearsing the task, not picturing the outcome you want.

    How to rehearse in your head

    Here is a simple way to add mental rehearsal to whatever you are preparing.

    1. Do it for real first

    It works best alongside real practice, so run it for real once first: the talk out loud, the piece played, the routine walked.

    2. Run it in order, at real speed

    Close your eyes and go through it from the start, in order, at roughly the speed you would do it for real. Do not skip ahead to the good bits. If you are rehearsing a talk, hear each point. If it is a movement, feel each step.

    3. Put yourself in the room

    See the place you will be in: the stage, the meeting room, the court, the exam hall. If the talk is on a memory palace, picture the palace laid out around that actual room. If you cannot get into the space beforehand, walk it in your mind.

    4. Rehearse the hard moment

    Every performance has a moment you are worried about: the high note, the tricky question, the line you always fluff. Rehearse that moment going well, and then run on from it.

    5. Notice where you go blank

    If you get stuck in your head, that is useful. It shows you exactly where the gap is. Do not panic and start again from the top. Make a note, then go and fix that part for real: look at it, practise it, give it a stronger cue.

    How many times before an audition, or going on stage, do you catch yourself running the lines in your head, only to go blank on one? It can set off a chain reaction. So do your mental runs early enough that a gap is something to fix, not something to worry about.

    6. Time it

    Do your runs early enough to fix what they show you: the day before is a good time for a full run. Close to the moment, keep it light.

    Where it fits

    Mental rehearsal sits naturally inside the rest of the memory work.

    For talks and presentations, run the talk through your memory palace in your head, one location per point, and see yourself giving each point as you arrive at it.

    For actors, it is part of the rehearsal process. How Actors Learn Lines Fast: The Seven-Step Recipe (From Learning Your Lines) shows where it sits among the other steps.

    For movement, a cut-down run-through without full effort can help you learn the order. How to Memorise a Dance Routine covers a study on dancers who rehearsed this way.

    For nerves, rehearse the room and the hard moment. Memory and Attention Exercises From the World of Acting shows how to walk a space, for real or in your mind, before you perform in it.

    Try it this week

    1. Pick one thing you are preparing: a talk, a conversation, a piece of music, a match.
    2. Do it once for real.
    3. Rehearse it once in your head, in order, at real speed, in the room where it will happen.
    4. Mark where you went blank and fix those parts for real.
    5. Run it in your head again the day before, early enough to fix any gaps.

    Memory map

    1. Mental rehearsal means running a task in your mind without doing it. Image: a person lying in bed, eyes closed, a tiny version of them giving a speech above the pillow.
    2. Driskell 1994: pooled studies found mental practice improves performance. Image: a row of lab notebooks stacked into one big book with a green tick on the cover.
    3. How much it helps depends on the task, how long you practise, and the gap before performing. Image: three dials on a mixing desk labelled with pictures of a ball, an hourglass and a calendar.
    4. Toth 2020: 37 newer studies, still helping, but the effect is small. Image: a small but sturdy seedling growing out of an old book.
    5. It is an add-on to real practice, not a replacement. Image: a sidecar bolted to a motorbike, both moving together.
    6. 235 Canadian Olympians: certain mental skills were linked to how they performed. Image: an athlete on a starting block, eyes closed, a maple leaf on their vest.
    7. Rehearsal is recall: you look for the words, and I see the testing effect at work. Image: a hand pulling a string of scenes out of a person's head like a magician's scarves.
    8. Do it once for real, then run it in order, at real speed, in the real room. Image: a person walking across a stage they have drawn in chalk on their living room floor.
    9. Rehearse the hard moment going well. Image: a singer hitting a high note while a nervous gremlin on their shoulder relaxes.
    10. Where you go blank shows you the gap; fix it for real. Image: a film strip with one blank frame, a pencil filling it in.
    11. Do your full run early enough to fix the gaps; keep it light close to the moment. Image: a clock beside a stage door, a mechanic tightening a bolt on the set well before curtain up.

    Sources

    • Driskell, J. E., Copper, C., and Moran, A. (1994). Does mental practice enhance performance? Journal of Applied Psychology, 79(4), 481 to 492. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.79.4.481
    • Toth, A. J., McNeill, E., Hayes, K., Moran, A. P., and Campbell, M. (2020). Does mental practice still enhance performance? A 24 year follow-up and meta-analytic replication and extension. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 48, 101672. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychsport.2020.101672
    • Orlick, T., and Partington, J. (1988). Mental links to excellence. The Sport Psychologist, 2(2), 105 to 130. https://doi.org/10.1123/tsp.2.2.105
    • Roediger, H. L., III, and Karpicke, J. D. (2006). Test-enhanced learning: taking memory tests improves long-term retention. Psychological Science, 17(3), 249 to 255. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2006.01693.x (the home for this study is The Testing Effect (Roediger and Karpicke 2006) Explained)
    • Warburton, E. C., Wilson, M., Lynch, M., and Cuykendall, S. (2013). The cognitive benefits of movement reduction: evidence from dance marking. Psychological Science, 24(9), 1732 to 1739. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797613478824 (the home for this study is How to Memorise a Dance Routine)

    Loci

    Build the memory palace in this article inside Loci — store your locations, link images, and rehearse with spaced repetition.

    Try it in Loci

    Memory School community

    Learn directly with Mark inside the Memory School community on Skool — monthly lessons, practice, and Q&A.

    Join Memory School

    About the author

    Grand Master of Memory (1995). Author of three books on memory published by Hodder and Nick Hern. Creator of BBC1's Monkhouse's Memory Masters. Memory coach on Channel 4's Can I Improve My Memory?

    Read full bio →