Implicit vs Explicit Memory: Knowing How and Knowing That

    How Memory Works

    Implicit vs Explicit Memory: Knowing How and Knowing That

    Explicit memory is what you can consciously recall. Implicit memory is what your body and brain know without being asked. The difference decides how you should learn a fact, a skill, and the moment one has to become the other.

    By Published Updated

    Explicit memory is anything you recall on purpose: the capital of Ireland, what you had for breakfast, the fact that Shakespeare wrote Hamlet. Implicit memory is anything you know without making any conscious effort to recall it: how to ride a bike, how to get your key into the lock in the dark, why a certain song makes you feel sixteen. Both are long-term memory. One of them you can talk about. The other you can only do.

    The split sounds like a textbook distinction, and it is, but it has a practical edge that is easy to miss. Learning problems often come down to using the wrong one. People try to think their way through a skill that should be in the body, or they try to drill a fact into the body when it needs a conscious hook. Get the distinction and you get a rule for how to learn anything.

    A two-minute test

    Try these two quickly.

    First, cover the page after reading this list once: tree, satellite, ghost, professor, reptile, ship, dinosaur, pirate. Now recall as many as you can. That effort, the deliberate reaching back, is explicit memory at work.

    Second, complete these fragments with whatever arrives first, no thinking allowed: Ele______, Pir______, Sat______, Gho______.

    If elephant, pirate, satellite and ghost arrived, notice that two of them came from the list you just read and two did not, and you probably could not feel the difference. Your brain used the words you had just seen to complete the stems without asking you. That is implicit memory, in this case a form called priming, and the effect is called the priming effect. You did not try to remember. Something in you remembered anyway.

    Most of what your memory does all day is the second kind.

    Explicit memory: knowing that

    Explicit memory is also called declarative memory, because you can declare it. It covers two things. Knowledge: facts, meanings, the periodic table, the fact that Rome is the capital of Italy. And experience: your own timeline of events, time-tagged and placed. Psychologists call the first semantic and the second episodic. They behave differently enough to get a full treatment in Episodic vs Semantic Memory: The Difference and Why It Matters, but they share the feature that matters here. You know you know them. You can search for them, find them and say them out loud.

    Explicit memory is the kind people mean when they say they have a bad memory. It is the kind that fails in exams, in meetings, when a name is on the tip of your tongue. And it is the kind that memory techniques were built for, because explicit memory responds to hooks: a picture, a place, a story, a sound. Give a bare fact one of those and it stops sliding off.

    The clearest evidence that explicit memory is its own system came from a patient known as H.M., who after surgery in 1953 could form no new facts or events at all, yet could still learn new skills without any memory of the lessons. The facts and the skills were in different places. That finding is where the split between the two kinds of memory begins.

    Implicit memory: knowing how

    Implicit memory, also called non-declarative, is a label for several kinds of non-conscious memory. They do not feel like memory from the inside. They feel like you.

    Procedural memory. Knowing how to do things: dance, drive, type, play a sport, make a cup of tea without looking at your hands. Built by repetition and doing, not by thinking. Once in, it stays. People who have not swum for twenty years swim.

    Priming. What the stem test showed. Exposure to something makes it easier to recognise or produce later, without any sense of recall. Priming is why a word you learned yesterday seems to appear everywhere today, and why the first thing you read in the morning colours what you notice all day.

    Conditioning. A response welded to a trigger. The dogs salivating at a bell is the famous version, but the everyday version is the song that changes your mood in three seconds, the smell that puts you back in a classroom, the flutter you get at the sound of a particular person's name. You did not decide any of it.

    Skills learning. The broad category of getting better at something through practice when you could not say what changed. A chess player sees the move. A good driver brakes before registering the hazard. The knowledge is real and useful, and it cannot be put into words.

    None of these can be improved by trying harder to remember. That is the whole point of them. They are built by exposure, repetition and doing, and they get stronger the less you think about them.

    The dive: why the split decides how you learn

    Here is where it stops being theory.

    Imagine you are learning to dive. One coach gives you the explicit version: push off with arms and legs at the same time, straighten your arms above your head, tuck your chin, keep the body in a line, drive with force. Every instruction is accurate. You could repeat them back word for word. Then you stand on the edge of the pool, try to run through six instructions in the half second available, and belly flop.

    Another coach gives you one image: you are a recoiled arrow ready to be fired from a crossbow, and when the trigger is pulled you shoot yourself into the water. No steps. Your body knows what an arrow does. You push with everything at once, your arms go straight, your head tucks, your body lines up, and while it is not a perfect dive it is recognisably a dive, and you can refine it from there.

    The research behind this is a 1992 study by Masters on what happens to a complex motor skill under pressure. When a skill has been learned explicitly, through detailed verbal instruction, pressure makes people start consciously running the instructions again, and the skill falls apart. People often call this paralysis by analysis; Masters described it as explicit knowledge being reinvested under pressure. Skills learned implicitly, without the verbal steps, held up far better when it mattered. Using a metaphor, like the arrow, is one way to take the implicit route; Masters did not test metaphors himself.

    So the rule is this. Facts want explicit learning with a hook. Skills want implicit learning with an image, because an image chunks the whole movement into one thing the body can do without a committee meeting.

    The same applies to any movement. In Pilates, the explicit instruction is to engage the pelvic floor and transversus abdominis, which is correct and useless to a beginner. The implicit instruction is to zip up your core, or to let the light in your centre drop gently into the floor. You may have no idea where those muscles are and you will still do roughly the right thing. Metaphor is how you hand a skill to implicit memory.

    When explicit has to become implicit

    Some of the most interesting learning sits on the border, where something starts explicit and must end implicit.

    An actor learning lines is the clearest case. The lines go in explicitly: you read them, you build visual cues (a small vivid image for each line that sparks its meaning), you can recite them. But a performance in which the actor is consciously recalling lines is a bad performance. You can see them reaching. The job is to move the words from the head into the body, so that in performance they arrive the way your hand arrives at a light switch, without being sent for. Retrieval practice, pulling the lines out of your head rather than reading them again, does this. Each time you recall a line you recreate it, and enough recreations make it procedural.

    The same border exists for a musician's scales, a surgeon's suturing, a driver's gear changes and a presenter's opening two minutes. All of them begin as instructions and must end as something you simply do. The mistake is to stay explicit too long, rehearsing the instructions when you should be doing the thing, or to go implicit too early, repeating a movement you have not yet understood and grooving in the error.

    Understand it explicitly. Then let your brain step out of the way so your body can do it.

    Using the split in daily life

    Three practical uses.

    Diagnose the problem before you pick a method. If you keep forgetting a client's name, that is an explicit failure and it needs a hook: an image for the name, a feature on the face to attach it to, the name said aloud. If you keep fluffing the same passage on the piano, that is an implicit failure and more thinking will make it worse. Slow it down, play it as one shape, build the repetitions.

    Use priming on purpose. Because implicit memory works without your permission, you can set it up. Glance through the glossary before reading a technical chapter and the terms will seem to leap out at you. Ask yourself what you want from a meeting before you walk in and your attention will find it. You cannot outsource this to anyone else. The priming has to happen in your head.

    Respect the body's memory. When a skill will not come, the answer is rarely another explanation. It is an image and a few hundred more goes. When a fact will not come, the answer is rarely another repetition. It is a picture and a place. Knowing which is which is most of the battle.

    The two systems in one sentence

    Explicit memory is what you know. Implicit memory is what you are. The first can be searched, spoken and improved with hooks; the second can only be built by doing and is undone by over-thinking. Learn facts with pictures and skills with metaphors, and let the border between them be crossed by practice, not by effort.

    For the full family tree of memory systems, Types of Memory: Working, Short-Term, Long-Term and More lays them out. For the skill side in depth, Procedural Memory Explained explains why skills last when facts fade. For the two halves of explicit memory, Episodic vs Semantic Memory: The Difference and Why It Matters. And for the conditioning branch, Conditioned Response: How Your Brain Learns to React Without You shows how triggers get welded to states, and how to weld your own.

    To work both sides of the border in real life, Animal Magic: Beat Paralysis by Analysis With Analogy Learning swaps a list of rules for one picture when a skill falls apart under thought, and How to Memorise a Dance Routine takes a routine from explicit steps to something your body simply does.

    Memory map

    Memory map for Implicit vs Explicit Memory: Knowing How and Knowing That: 11 numbered images, one for each key idea in the article

    1. Explicit memory is conscious recall; implicit memory is knowing without trying. Image: a person reading from an open book while their hands tie a shoelace without looking.
    2. The word-stem test: Ele______ becomes elephant because you were primed. Image: a half-written word on a blackboard with an elephant pushing through the gap.
    3. Explicit covers knowledge and experience; it is the kind that fails in exams and responds to hooks. Image: a library shelf with a coat hook screwed to the end of it.
    4. The 1953 patient kept learning skills while forming no new facts; the two systems are separate. Image: a man drawing a perfect star while the page of a diary behind him stays blank.
    5. Four kinds of implicit memory: procedural, priming, conditioning, skills learning. Image: a bicycle, a half-finished word, a ringing bell and a chessboard in a row.
    6. The dive: six explicit instructions produce a belly flop; one image of a crossbow arrow produces a dive. Image: a diver leaving the board as a drawn arrow in flight.
    7. Masters 1992: skills learned through explicit rules were more likely to break down under pressure. Image: a golfer frozen mid-swing with a scroll of instructions unrolling from their head.
    8. Facts want hooks; skills want images and repetitions. Image: a fact hanging from a hook on one side, a body moving as one shape on the other.
    9. Zip up your core beats engage your transversus abdominis. Image: a zip running up the front of a torso.
    10. Explicit becomes implicit through practice: lines move from the head into the body. Image: words drifting down from a head into a pair of hands on a stage.
    11. Prime yourself on purpose; nobody can do it for you. Image: a person flicking through a glossary before opening a thick chapter.

    Sources

    • Mark Channon, How to Remember Anything (Hodder Education)
    • Mark Channon, The Memory Workbook (Hodder Education)
    • Masters, R. S. W. (1992). Knowledge, knerves and know-how: the role of explicit versus implicit knowledge in the breakdown of a complex motor skill under pressure. British Journal of Psychology, 83(3), 343 to 358. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2044-8295.1992.tb02446.x
    • Scoville, W. B. and Milner, B. (1957). Loss of recent memory after bilateral hippocampal lesions. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry, 20(1), 11 to 21. https://doi.org/10.1136/jnnp.20.1.11

    Loci

    Build the memory palace in this article inside Loci — store your locations, link images, and rehearse with spaced repetition.

    Try it in Loci

    Memory School community

    Learn directly with Mark inside the Memory School community on Skool — monthly lessons, practice, and Q&A.

    Join Memory School

    About the author

    Grand Master of Memory (1995). Author of three books on memory published by Hodder and Nick Hern. Creator of BBC1's Monkhouse's Memory Masters. Memory coach on Channel 4's Can I Improve My Memory?

    Read full bio →